My sister and I were born 14 months apart. They call it Irish twins. If we had been born on opposite sides of the world, we would have been quite different.
Julia, the golden child. Always was. The one with wide brown eyes, beautiful hair that always looked professional, and this easy, natural manner of communicating. Teachers adored her. She was adored by neighbors. My parents believed she was a second coming of something sacred.
And I? I was the Sharpie-drawing child. He loathed piano lessons and was detentioned for calling an instructor “a smug piece of toast.” I wasn’t bad—just not Julia.
Not always was growing up under her shadow traumatic. At first, it seemed natural. Julia earned acclaim and I got leftovers. After winning her first countywide violin competition, she had a late-night dinner party with wine, steak, and laughing. When I was published in the school literary magazine, Mom nodded and remarked, “That’s nice.”
I accepted that I would pay my own way by the time high school concluded. Julia received the automobile. Julia visited Europe before college. Julia had complete parental support while choosing institutions.
Me? I received a hug and student loan literature.
I recall Dad’s precise remarks when I asked why.
He responded, “She deserves it,” without glancing up from the newspaper. “But you don’t.”
I wish I cried. Or shouted. But I didn’t. Just exited the room. I always thought people showed who they were if you were open to it.
But I persisted. I applied for every scholarship I could. I borrowed. I had two summer and one semester jobs. I seldom partied. Never joined a sorority. I did study. I studied for my life. It did, kind of.
Julia and I attended the same state university—different majors, dormitories, lifestyles. Sometimes we met on campus. She constantly had company on her way to club meetings or socials. Me? Walking directly to the library or dining hall with earphones and coffee was my typical routine.
We weren’t hostile. We weren’t close either. Not anymore.
Four years later. Day of graduation.
Under their black robes, it was scorching. All were fanning themselves with programs and holding their hats like kites. I glanced at the podium from the sea of seats with hats bobbing in the sun. I was calm. Not even thrilled. I was mostly exhausted. Tired in your bones, spirit, and hidden places.
But I did it. Against all odds. Contrary to expectations. Assisted only by myself.
Two seats forward, Julia waved to a crowd member. Maybe Mom and Dad. I didn’t search. I knew where they were. Front row seats, camera in hand, eager to capture their beloved child’s victory.
When Julia’s name was mentioned, they whooped and cheered so loudly the dean cringed.
When my name was called, quiet. Some polite stranger applause.
I crossed the stage, collected my diploma, smiled for the camera, and left. The end.
The true story? Unpredicted twist? One hour later, at the dinner hall.
Honors graduates—department heads, professors, deans, and top students—ate lunch. I hadn’t informed my parents I was going. I doubt they realized I graduated with honors. They never inquired about it.
But Julia knew. Last semester, she seemed surprised when we ran into each other and she noticed the “Honors Thesis” folder under my arm.
“You’re doing a thesis?” she inquired.
“Yes,” I answered. “Research-based. Actually won a departmental award.”
Her eyebrows rose. “Oh. Wow.”
Only that. But that was the first time she looked at me like she didn’t know me.
We attended the luncheon. White-clothed tables, centerpieces, fluted sparkling juice. The College of Social Sciences dean spoke. Poking at my plate, I half-listened. He hesitated and took out paper.
“We have a special recognition today,” he remarked. We give one university-wide student the Chancellor’s Medal for Outstanding Achievement each year. The winner has shown resilience, leadership, and personal development in addition to academic accomplishment. This year’s honoree inspires our teachers with their commitment and perseverance.”
I scarcely glanced up. Cutting overcooked chicken was my focus.
Join me in congratulating—Lena Harper.”
I froze.
Did he—
Everyone looked at me. My fork rattled on the platter.
I stood perplexed, blinking slowly. Someone nudges me. There was applause.
Dazed, I stepped onstage. Dean shook my hand, gave me certificate, and leaned closer.
“You deserve this. Your thesis excelled. You touched many with your story.”
Julia was there when I returned to the room.
She was with her parents at the banquet hall’s rear.
They had pallid faces.
Mom had a slightly wide lips, like she had swallowed something nasty. Dad crossed his arms. Julia was dumbfounded. Like she saw a ghost.
Later, I learned they didn’t know I was honored.
They didn’t read the university’s press statement last week. The programme wasn’t checked. Julia was their main concern. They were surprised I was called. That I would get the university’s top honor.
After lunch, they approached me carefully. Tight, uncomfortable grin from Julia.
“Congratulations,” she said. Wow, that was incredible.
Thanks, I said. I meant it. No matter what, Julia was never unkind.
Mom and Dad were quiet.
Mom spoke brittlely. “Why didn’t you say?”
I blinked. Would it have mattered?
She recoiled.
Cleared his throat. “It’s not always about awards and flashy recognition. Some folks do their duties without much fuss.
I glanced at him, wondering what version of myself he was rewriting.
I told my dad, “I paid for college myself. Every credit. I worked weekends and evenings. I tutor. Was an intern. I finished with a 3.98 GPA, published a thesis, and am starting a fully supported PhD program at Stanford this fall.”
Their mouths opened. All three.
You never asked, therefore I didn’t tell you. Not once. And I didn’t need your permission to arrive.”
The stillness was lengthy.
Then Julia murmured, “Stanford?”
I nodded. “Full ride. Plus stipend. I’ll study policy and education equity.”
Dad mumbled something. Mom looked tearful.
Without comforting them, I left.
I turned, thanked my instructors, and left in the afternoon light with the medal.
In recent months, I haven’t talked to my parents. Julia and I text periodically. She looks content teaching English in a high school, which makes me happy. I don’t dislike her. She didn’t establish the hierarchy—we were born into it.
I learnt that your loudest successes may not be applauded by those you need it from. Sometimes they arrive softly, like standing tall when no one expects you to. As you pass a stage no one thought you’d reach.
Their approbation isn’t what you recall.
It’s your pride.